Chapter 4: The Best Hardwood Species for Cooking
Many hardwood species will enhance the taste of your food while also providing the high heat necessary for thorough cooking. But obviously, you can’t use all of them at the same time. Nor would you want to because it probably wouldn’t taste too good!
Instead, you must choose wisely to select the species that will perfectly complement the food you’re cooking. This is a safer bet with some types of hardwood than others.
For example, mesquite is a hardwood that produces an incredibly potent flavor, which is ideal for barbequing dark meat. However, because its smoke is so powerful, it’s easy to overdo it with mesquite. So, you may want to avoid this type of wood at first if you’re just getting started with wood-fired cooking.
This begs the question: Which hardwood species are best for novice wood-fired chefs? We’ve put together a list of a few reliable woods that we recommend trying:
Oak
Oak is the most versatile and beloved cooking wood of all. It produces a ton of heat—averaging around 29 million British Thermal Units (BTUs) per cord—without overpowering the flavor of what it cooks. Instead, its smoke adds a moderate amount of subtle, smoky flavor for that classic wood-fired taste.
The best thing about oak is you can cook just about anything with it, including pizza, seafood, vegetables and virtually all meats. So, if you’re looking for the safest wood for your first time smoking meat or wood-firing pizza, we recommend trying oak.
Hickory
A more flavorful cooking wood than oak is hickory. Like oak, it generates an awesome heat output of 28 million BTUs per cord. However, the taste it creates is much more noticeable and potent. People often say hickory smoke has a hearty and savory flavor, similar to bacon. Because of this, hickory is one of the most popular choices for smoking or grilling meat.
Since it’s more flavorful than oak, hickory can be a bit more challenging to use. The powerful smoke it produces can overpower the food you’re cooking if you use too much. So, remember that a little goes a long way when it comes to hickory. You may want to consider mixing it with a more neutrally flavored wood like oak to balance it out.
Cherry
Whereas oak and hickory are great choices for a smoky flavor, cherry is for those of us who like a little fruity sweetness with our smoke.
Cherry comes harvested from cherry trees and has the same pinkish-reddish hue as the fruit it produces. The wood burns with a moderate amount of heat at about 20 million BTUs per cord and adds a hint of cherry taste and color to whatever it cooks.
We recommend trying cherry with a variety of different meats, especially turkey, ham, lamb and wild game. You also can’t go wrong adding some cherry to your pizza oven for a smoky sweet pie!
Apple
Apple is another hardwood that produces smoke with a hint of fruity flavor. It has a higher heat output than cherry at 27 million BTUs per cord and is an excellent choice for smoking pork, poultry, cheese and ribs. Apple also mixes well with oak or hickory for a mix of smoky and sweet flavors.
Sugar Maple
One final hardwood we love is sugar maple wood. Like cherry and apple, sugar maple produces a subtly sweet flavor, but instead of fruit, the smoke tastes faintly of maple syrup!
Sugar maple goes great with a variety of meats, vegetables and cheeses. It also mixes well with any of the other types of wood listed above.
Here at Lumberjacks, we sell kiln-dried oak, hickory, cherry and apple cooking wood. We don’t have sugar maple, but our friends at Hot Box Cooking Wood do! So, we recommend checking out their selection here.